Fantasy football All Fade picks raise caution on big names

A pointed take on why some top players may not be worth their 2025 draft price and what this means for strategy.

Fantasy football All Fade picks raise caution on big names

Michael Salfino identifies players priced too high for 2025 fantasy drafts and suggests buyers should focus on where the market undervalues potential upside. Using FantasyPros half PPR ADP and his own rankings, he notes that formats vary and that owners must adapt to league structure, WR depth, and RB scarcity. In 1 QB leagues, quarterbacks come off the board in predictable ways, but the real discipline is avoiding overpaying for hype. He flags Kyler Murray as overpriced at consensus QB9, pointing to a career profile that lagging in key passing metrics while relying on rushing yards that may deteriorate with wear. He also questions Christian McCaffrey’s durability and age, Alvin Kamara’s age 30 season and uncertain offense, and Xavier Worthy’s limited intermediate usage, arguing these do not justify lofty price tags. Other mentions include Evan Engram’s age and speed concerns and rookie Matthew Golden’s bust risk, emphasizing the uncertainty that comes with hype and rookies.

The piece argues that the biggest edge comes from price discipline and roster breadth. It stresses that valuable assets can be found by targeting players with clearer, versatile roles and by avoiding single star bets when a deeper, safer floor is available. The overall takeaway is a call for patience and careful market reading, especially in formats that emphasize depth and flexible lineups.

The analysis highlights a core truth of fantasy sports: markets overreact to name value. By focusing on Price over polish, managers can build more resilient rosters. The piece implicitly urges readers to hunt for players with sustainable roles, not just speed or headline moments. It also underlines the risk of aging backs and quarterbacks who rely on rushing without consistent passing success. In short, value is earned by discounting hype and elevating versatility and durability across positions.

Highlights

Patience and discipline stay your best draft tools.