Scottish Secretary criticizes Edinburgh Council over fan remarks

Ian Murray accused Edinburgh Council of classist attitudes towards Oasis fans.

Scottish Secretary criticizes Edinburgh council for Oasis fans remarks

Scottish Secretary Ian Murray has labeled the City of Edinburgh Council as "snobby" following comments made about Oasis fans prior to the band's upcoming shows at Murrayfield Stadium. Murray's criticism stemmed from a safety briefing that described fans as "rowdy," "intoxicated," and "middle-aged men" who "take up more room." He expressed these views during a conversation at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, arguing that such language reflects a classist attitude. The safety advisory meeting included representatives from various services, who raised concerns about the anticipated crowd of around 70,000 fans, especially regarding their behavior on weekends. Murray highlighted the double standards regarding alcohol regulations between rugby and football fans, questioning why rugby spectators can drink freely while football fans face restrictions.

Murray's comments highlight broader societal attitudes towards different types of fans and public events. His critique suggests a tension between how various audiences, particularly in sports and music, are perceived and treated. The characterization of Oasis fans by the council may reflect an underlying class bias, especially when viewed in contrast to rugby fans at events. This instance underscores a potential need for a reevaluation of how authorities engage with diverse crowds, emphasizing equality regardless of the event type. As music events like Oasis now draw large crowds after a long hiatus, this situation may spark further discussions on class and access to public enjoyment.

Highlights

The ongoing discourse may push for fairer treatment in future events.