T4K3.news

Pirates trade Falter and Rogers but miss key opportunities

The Pirates have traded Bailey Falter and Taylor Rogers but secured no major-league-ready players.

July 31, 2025 at 10:12 PM

Ben Cherington's last-minute Cubs, Royals trades are too little, too late for Pirates

The Pirates traded Bailey Falter to the Royals and Taylor Rogers to the Cubs, but key trade candidates remain on the board.

Ben Cherington fails to make impactful trades for Pirates

The Pittsburgh Pirates' recent trade moves included sending Bailey Falter to the Royals and Taylor Rogers to the Cubs, both completed just minutes before the trade deadline. These decisions come after earlier trades involving key players like Ke'Bryan Hayes, Caleb Ferguson, and David Bednar. While the Pirates received some prospects in return, they did not secure any major-league-ready players or significant bats, which they desperately needed. With other attractive trade candidates like Tommy Pham and Isiah Kiner-Falefa remaining untraded, many fans and analysts question the effectiveness of Ben Cherington's strategy at the deadline.

Key Takeaways

✔️

The Pirates made late trades but received minimal returns.

✔️

No major-league-ready talent was added to the roster.

✔️

Other key players were not traded, raising eyebrows in the fanbase.

✔️

The offense remains largely unchanged despite key departures.

✔️

Cherington's trading strategy appears short-sighted.

✔️

Missed opportunities may affect team morale going forward.

"Cherington let a precious, short window close right in front of his eyes."

This reflects the frustration with the lack of significant trades from the Pirates.

"Fans never want their team to be sellers, but they had a golden opportunity to bring in talent."

This emphasizes the disappointment in the trades the Pirates made.

This trade deadline revealed the Pirates' missed opportunities and left questions about the team's future. The decision not to leverage the strong market for Tommy Pham was particularly striking, considering his recent performance. Cherington's focus on immediate trades without addressing deeper issues in the lineup could hinder the Pirates' prospects for growth. Viewing players as commodities is often essential in professional sports, yet Cherington's reluctance to secure impactful trades leaves the organization at a crucial crossroads.