favicon

T4K3.news

Handball call sparks debate

Analysis of the Senesi handball moment in Liverpool vs Bournemouth and the split views from Clattenburg and Carragher.

August 15, 2025 at 08:00 PM
blur Mark Clattenburg and Jamie Carragher disagree on Marcos Senesi handball in Liverpool v Bournemouth

Exclusive analysis of Marcos Senesi’s handball moment in Liverpool versus Bournemouth and how two former professionals frame the call.

Clattenburg backs referee decision as Carragher disputes Senesi handball call

Liverpool opened their Premier League season with a 1-0 win over Bournemouth after Mohamed Salah set up a first-half goal for Hugo Ekitike. In the 13th minute, Senesi stretched to clear a forward pass and the ball appeared to catch his hand, but referee Anthony Taylor did not award a foul or a red card and the decision went unchallenged by VAR.

Key Takeaways

✔️
The decision aligns with a recent handball rule approach that emphasizes contact origin and arm involvement.
✔️
Real time calls can differ from what replays show, fueling ongoing debates about officiating.
✔️
Pundits from different corners of the game can view the same moment very differently.
✔️
Early season refereeing decisions can influence match momentum and public perception.
✔️
VAR remains a live source of scrutiny in the Premier League and among fans.
✔️
Consistency in how handball is judged across matches is a growing concern.
✔️
Clearer, more consistent guidelines would help restore trust in officiating.

"This decision of the referee, Anthony Taylor, not to penalise Marcos Senesi for handball is a correct call."

Clattenburg's exclusive perspective

"The defender handled the ball."

Carragher on Sky Sports commentary

"I don’t like football to be refereed in slow motion."

Clattenburg on replays

In an exclusive follow-up, Mark Clattenburg argues the call was correct under current rules, saying the ball deflected off the leg onto the arm and should be judged as playing the ball onto the arm. He notes the law was updated to curb penalties when contact comes from a defender’s leg and points to the Premier League’s stricter stance on handball compared with some European leagues. He also cautions against judging actions in slow motion, which can distort the moment.

Highlights

  • Real time calls win over slow motion replay
  • Handball rules need to feel fair to players and fans
  • Pundits differ but the law remains the law
  • Referees act in the moment not in a loop

The handball debate will keep testing the game’s fairness as the season unfolds.

Enjoyed this? Let your friends know!

Related News