T4K3.news

Elderly choking devices face scrutiny

Experts voice concerns over the effectiveness of new anti-choking devices for the elderly.

July 14, 2025 at 04:18 PM

A device or the Heimlich maneuver: What to do when someone is choking

Choking remains a leading cause of death among older adults, prompting debates on preventive devices.

Elderly choking prevention raises concerns over device effectiveness

In the United States, more than 4,100 seniors die from choking each year, with a growing population at risk. Notably, life-saving measures such as the Heimlich maneuver and back slaps remain vital, yet there is increasing interest in new anti-choking devices. These products, marketed under names like LifeVac and Dechoker, aim to assist when traditional techniques fail. However, experts like Dr. Nathan Charlton from the University of Virginia emphasize that evidence supporting these devices is limited. While some manufacturers claim these products have saved lives, regulatory concerns exist, as the FDA has not approved any of these devices for safety and efficacy. Meanwhile, researchers stress that existing methods, including back blows and abdominal thrusts, should always be the first response in choking emergencies.

Key Takeaways

✔️

Choking is a leading cause of death among older adults.

✔️

New anti-choking devices are controversial and unproven.

✔️

Traditional methods remain essential for choking emergencies.

✔️

Efforts to market these devices grow amid rising elder populations.

"This was by far the worst one I’ve been on in my career."

Fire department captain David Palumbo reflects on a serious choking incident he responded to.

"The FDA has not approved antichoking devices sold over the counter, because their safety and effectiveness haven’t been established."

A warning from the FDA emphasizes concerns over the unproven nature of these devices.

"We’re only now getting good evidence on the old choking techniques, let alone these new ones."

Researcher Dr. Cody Dunne points out the lack of solid evidence for both new and traditional choking treatments.

As choking incidents among elderly individuals rise, the push for innovative devices indicates a crucial trend in emergency care. However, as the debate unfolds over the reliability of these products, it is essential to maintain focus on proven first-aid techniques. The hesitation from medical professionals highlights the need for rigorous research before widespread encouragement of these devices. Until then, educating caregivers and the elderly about effective response methods may prevent unnecessary tragedies.