Court blocks DEI guidance in school policy

A federal judge blocked two Education Department memos aimed at ending race based considerations in schools, signaling a legal constraint on DEI policy.

Judge blocks DEI guidance in school policy

A federal judge in Maryland ruled that two Education Department memos ordering schools to end all race based decision making and to drop DEI programs violated federal law by threatening to cut federal funding. The ruling follows a February lawsuit filed by the American Federation of Teachers and the American Sociological Association. Judge Stephanie Gallagher ordered the department to scrap the guidance, saying it failed procedural requirements even as she left open the question of the policies merits.

The decision comes after prior injunctions blocked parts of the measures and reflects a broader clash over how civil rights are defined in education. The Education Department said Title VI protections remain enforceable and that the ruling does not stop the department from acting, even as the memos are set aside. Supporters say the ruling safeguards teachers and students from political pressure, while opponents warn it could slow efforts to address disparities.

The ruling tests how far federal policy can push schools to change admissions or hiring practices. It emphasizes due process and legal standards over policy aims, suggesting courts will demand procedural rigor in politically sensitive areas. It also highlights a continuing fault line between federal power and campus autonomy that will shape future policy fights.

As DEI debates move through courts, educators and lawmakers will weigh enforcement against the goal of equal opportunity. The decision may cool aggressive tactics but could also fuel new challenges from both sides, keeping the issue in the legal arena for years to come.

Highlights

The debate over DEI and federal policy on campus life is far from over.