BYU names Bachmeier starting quarterback for 2025

Bear Bachmeier steps in as BYU’s starting quarterback in 2025, with early tests at home and a Big 12 schedule looming.

BYU goes forward with history naming rookie QB to start in 2025

BYU announced Bear Bachmeier will start at quarterback as a true freshman for the 2025 season. He becomes the first true freshman to begin a season as a starter for BYU in Provo, and the opening slate includes two home games before a Big 12 schedule many see as manageable that year.

The coaching staff can fallback to veteran McCae Hillstead if Bachmeier hits rough patches. Experts note Bachmeier brings brains and talent to the role, but the true test will come in real games and in how well the supporting cast around him performs, especially Chase Roberts who is expected to draw double teams.

The offense could lean on versatile pieces such as Carsen Ryan to create space and misdirection, while young receivers around Roberts have upside but lack extensive game experience. Kalani Sitake and the staff have stressed that the season is about growth as much as results in the early stages, with the opener against Portland State serving as an initial gauge of how the plan translates to the game clock.

Starting Bachmeier as a true freshman signals a development first approach from BYU, a gamble that tests coaching confidence, player readiness, and the pace of the Big 12.

The plan hinges on a blend of protection, play design, and playmakers. If the receivers don’t produce, Bachmeier’s growth could stall; if Ryan and the tight end can be weapons, the offense has a path to move the ball even with a young quarterback.

Long term, success could accelerate BYU’s recruiting narrative and fan optimism, while failure might prompt adjustments in how the program balances immediate results with player development. This season will illuminate a broader trend in college football toward empowering younger players early when the talent pool supports it.

Highlights

Patience timing and a little luck will decide this season's story.